I have read scripts for three decades: for plays I directed, serials I wrote for, and now for writers who send them to Story Doctor. The good news is that most problems show up early. Here is what I look for before page ten.
Whose story is it?
By page three I want to know who we are following and what they want. Not their whole life, just what they want today. A script with five equal characters in the first scene usually has no centre.
What is the promise?
Every story makes a promise early: this will be a love story, a crime, a fight against the odds. The audience relaxes once they know the game. Many first drafts hide the promise for too long because the writer thinks mystery equals interest. It doesn’t. Questions keep us watching; confusion makes us leave.
Does each scene change something?
If you can cut a scene and nothing in the story is lost, cut it. In the first ten pages every scene should move the main character closer to, or further from, what they want.
Do people talk like people?
Dialogue that explains the plot is the most common fault I see. People rarely say what they mean, and almost never say what the audience needs to know. Read your lines aloud. If an actor would struggle to say one, rewrite it.
Is the world specific?
“A small town” is nothing. “A town where the only cinema shows films a year late” is a world. One true, specific detail does more than a page of description.
None of this is a formula. Rules are useful for diagnosis, not for writing. But if a script works in its first ten pages, I usually find the rest is a matter of craft. If it doesn’t, no amount of polish later will save it.